Instant Pot vs. Ninja Foodi: Which Multi-Cooker Wins in 2025?
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Instant Pot vs. Ninja Foodi – The multi-cooker revolution is here to stay. What started with the iconic Instant Pot has evolved into a competitive market, with the Ninja Foodi emerging as a powerful contender. Both promise to save you time, counter space, and effort. But which one is the right long-term investment for your kitchen in 2025?
This isn’t about which one is “better” in a vacuum. It’s about which one is better for you. Having used both for years, I’m breaking down their key features, performance, and overall value to help you decide which multi-cooker wins for your needs.
Instant Pot vs Ninja Foodi: Core Differences in Design
-
Instant Pot: The original game-changer. Its philosophy is masterful precision pressure cooking. It excels at making hands-off, set-it-and-forget-it meals like soups, stews, beans from scratch, and perfectly cooked grains. Many models focus on doing this one thing exceptionally well.
-
Ninja Foodi: The ambitious innovator. Its philosophy is “all-in-one” versatility. It’s designed not just to pressure cook, but to replace your air fryer and often your toaster oven. The defining feature is the integrated TenderCrisp™ lid, which adds air frying and crisping capabilities without needing a separate appliance.
Head-to-Head Breakdown: 2025 Showdown
| Feature | Instant Pot (e.g., Duo Series) | Ninja Foodi (e.g., OL701) | And the Winner Is… |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pressure Cooking | Excellent. The gold standard. Consistent, reliable, and intuitive. | Excellent. Performs just as well as Instant Pot for core pressure cooking tasks. | It’s a Tie. Both are masters of the pressure cook. |
| Air Frying | Requires a separate, often sold-separately, air fryer lid attachment. | Built-in. The TenderCrisp™ lid is integrated, making air frying seamless. | Ninja Foodi. The built-in functionality is more convenient and cohesive. |
| Versatility | Great at pressure cooking, slow cooking, yogurt making. | Superior. Pressure cooks, air fries, bakes, roasts, dehydrates, and more all in one unit. | Ninja Foodi. It simply does more without adding extra parts. |
| Ease of Use | Simple, straightforward controls. A classic for a reason. | Can have a steeper learning curve due to its many functions. | Instant Pot. Slightly easier for beginners to pick up and use. |
| Counter Space | One compact base unit. (Lid stored separately if you have the air fryer attachment). | One larger unit with a permanently attached crisping lid. | Instant Pot. Has a slightly smaller footprint and a less bulky profile. |
| Yogurt Making | A standout feature. Most models have a precise “Yogurt” function. | Often lacks a dedicated yogurt setting or doesn’t maintain the low, precise temp as well. | Instant Pot. The clear winner for homemade yogurt enthusiasts. |
| Price Point | Generally more affordable for the base models. | Often a higher initial investment, but you’re getting an air fryer built-in. | Depends. Instant Pot is cheaper upfront, but the Foodi may offer better value by replacing two appliances. |
Who Should Choose the Instant Pot?
The Instant Pot is your winner if you:
-
Are primarily interested in mastering pressure cooking (soups, stocks, tough cuts of meat).
-
Want to make yogurt at home regularly.
-
Prefer a simpler, more straightforward interface.
-
Have a ** smaller budget** upfront.
-
Don’t care about air frying or already own a dedicated air fryer you love.
Who Should Choose the Ninja Foodi?
The Ninja Foodi is your winner if you:
-
Want true all-in-one functionality and want to replace your air fryer.
-
Love the idea of pressure cooking chicken thighs and then crisping the skin in the same pot without moving the food.
-
Value versatility (baking, dehydrating) over simplicity.
-
Are willing to learn a slightly more complex system for greater reward.
-
Have the counter space for its larger, taller design.
The 2025 Verdict: Which Multi-Cooker Wins?
Looking ahead, the trend is toward multi-functionality. This gives the Ninja Foodi a slight edge as the winner for most people in 2025.
Why? The ability to air fry and crisp directly after pressure cooking is a transformative feature that the standard Instant Pot can’t match without an extra purchase and storage hassle. For a modern kitchen, a device that can pressure cook, air fry, roast, and bake is an incredible value and a massive space-saver.
However, the real winner is you. Both are exceptional appliances.
-
Choose Instant Pot for unparalleled pressure cooking and yogurt-making simplicity.
-
Choose Ninja Foodi for maximum versatility and the ultimate “do-it-all” countertop machine.
Your decision ultimately comes down to your cooking style and which features you’ll use most. You can’t go wrong, but in the battle for the future of the kitchen, the all-in-one Ninja Foodi takes the crown.
Ready to Claim Your Kitchen Champion?
See which one fits your style and check the latest prices.
➡️ Click here for the latest deals on Ninja Foodi Multi-Cookers on Amazon
➡️ Click here for the latest deals on Instant Pot Multi-Cookers on Amazon
Contributors
David Chen
David is passionate about blending technology with everyday living. From smart home devices to travel gear, he reviews products with a sharp eye for usability, durability, and design.